• Overview
    • Automated PKI Infrastructure
    • Data Encryption & Tokenization
    • Database Credential Rotation
    • Dynamic Secrets
    • Identity-based Access
    • Key Management
    • Kubernetes Secrets
    • Secrets Management
  • Enterprise
  • Tutorials
  • Docs
  • API
  • Community
GitHubTry Cloud
Download
    • v1.11.x (latest)
    • v1.10.x
    • v1.9.x
    • v1.8.x
    • v1.7.x
    • v1.6.x
    • v1.5.x
    • v1.4.x
  • What is Vault?
  • Use Cases
    • CLI Quick Start
    • HCP Quick Start
    • Developer Quick Start

  • Browser Support
  • Installing Vault
    • Overview
    • Architecture
    • High Availability
    • Integrated Storage
    • Security Model
    • Telemetry
    • Token Authentication
    • Key Rotation
    • Replication
    • Limits and Maximums
    • Overview
    • 'Dev' Server
    • Seal/Unseal
    • Namespace API Lock
    • Lease, Renew, and Revoke
    • Authentication
    • Tokens
    • Identity
    • OIDC Provider
    • Response Wrapping
    • Policies
    • Password Policies
    • Username Templating
    • High Availability
    • Storage
      • Overview
      • Autopilot
    • PGP, GnuPG, and Keybase
    • Recovery Mode
    • Resource Quotas
      • Overview
      • FAQ
    • Transform
    • Mount Migration
    • Overview
      • Overview
      • TCP
    • replication
      • Overview
      • AliCloud KMS
      • AWS KMS
      • Azure Key Vault
      • GCP Cloud KMS
      • OCI KMS
      • HSM PKCS11 ENT
      • Vault Transit
    • sentinel
      • Overview
      • Consul
      • Kubernetes
      • Overview
      • Aerospike
      • Alicloud OSS
      • Azure
      • Cassandra
      • CockroachDB
      • Consul
      • CouchDB
      • DynamoDB
      • Etcd
      • Filesystem
      • FoundationDB
      • Google Cloud Spanner
      • Google Cloud Storage
      • In-Memory
      • Manta
      • MSSQL
      • MySQL
      • OCI Object Storage
      • PostgreSQL
      • Integrated Storage (Raft)
      • S3
      • Swift
      • Zookeeper
    • telemetry
    • ui
    • Log Completed Requests
    • Entropy Augmentation ENT
    • kms_library ENT
    • Overview
    • agent
      • Overview
      • disable
      • enable
      • list
      • Overview
      • disable
      • enable
      • help
      • list
      • move
      • tune
    • debug
    • delete
      • Overview
      • delete
      • destroy
      • enable-versioning
      • get
      • list
      • metadata
      • patch
      • put
      • rollback
      • undelete
      • Overview
      • lookup
      • renew
      • revoke
      • Overview
      • get
      • inspect
    • list
    • login
    • monitor
    • namespace
      • Overview
      • diagnose
      • generate-root
      • init
      • key-status
      • members
      • migrate
      • raft
      • rekey
      • rotate
      • seal
      • step-down
      • unseal
      • usage
    • path-help
      • Overview
      • deregister
      • info
      • list
      • register
      • reload
      • Overview
      • delete
      • fmt
      • list
      • read
      • write
    • read
      • Overview
      • disable
      • enable
      • list
      • move
      • tune
    • server
    • ssh
    • status
      • Overview
      • capabilities
      • create
      • lookup
      • renew
      • revoke
    • unwrap
    • version
    • version-history
    • write
    • Token Helpers
    • Overview
      • Overview
        • Overview
        • AliCloud
        • AppRole
        • AWS
        • Azure
        • Cert
        • CF
        • GCP
        • JWT
        • Kerberos
        • Kubernetes
        • Overview
        • File
      • Overview
        • Overview
        • Kubernetes
    • Templates
    • Windows service

    • Overview
    • Active Directory
    • AliCloud
    • AWS
    • Azure
    • Consul
    • Cubbyhole
      • Overview
      • Cassandra
      • Couchbase
      • Elasticsearch
      • HanaDB
      • IBM Db2
      • InfluxDB
      • MongoDB
      • MongoDB Atlas
      • MSSQL
      • MySQL/MariaDB
      • Oracle
      • PostgreSQL
      • Redshift
      • Snowflake
      • Custom
    • Google Cloud
    • Google Cloud KMS
      • Overview
      • Identity Tokens
      • OIDC Identity Provider
      • Overview
      • Azure Key Vault
      • AWS KMS
      • GCP Cloud KMS
      • Overview
      • K/V Version 1
      • K/V Version 2
    • KMIP ENTERPRISE
    • Kubernetes
    • MongoDB Atlas
    • Nomad
    • OpenLDAP
      • Overview
      • Setup and Usage
      • Quick Start - Root CA Setup
      • Quick Start - Intermediate CA Setup
      • Considerations
      • Rotation Primitives
    • RabbitMQ
      • Overview
      • Signed Certificates
      • SSH OTP
      • Dynamic Key
    • Terraform Cloud
    • TOTP
      • Overview
      • FF3-1 Tweak Usage
      • Tokenization Transform ENTERPRISE
    • Transit
    • Venafi (Certificates)
    • Overview
    • AppRole
    • AliCloud
    • AWS
    • Azure
    • Cloud Foundry
    • GitHub
    • Google Cloud
      • Overview
      • OIDC Providers
    • Kerberos
    • Kubernetes
    • LDAP
      • Overview
      • FAQ
    • Oracle Cloud Infrastructure
    • Okta
    • RADIUS
    • TLS Certificates
    • Tokens
    • Username & Password

    • App ID DEPRECATED
    • Overview
    • File
    • Syslog
    • Socket
    • Overview
    • Plugin Architecture
    • Plugin Development
    • Plugin Management
    • Plugin Portal
  • Vault Integration Program
  • Troubleshoot

    • Overview
      • Overview
      • Agent Injector vs. Vault CSI Provider
        • Overview
        • Running Vault
        • Enterprise Licensing
        • Running Vault on OpenShift
        • Configuration
          • Overview
          • Development
          • Standalone with Load Balanced UI
          • Standalone with TLS
          • Standalone with Audit Storage
          • External Vault
          • Using Kubernetes Auth Method
          • HA Cluster with Consul
          • HA Cluster with Raft
          • HA Enterprise Cluster with Raft
          • HA Enterprise DR Clusters with Raft
          • HA Enterprise Performance Clusters with Raft
          • Vault Agent Injector TLS Configuration
          • Vault Agent Injector TLS with Cert-Manager
        • Overview
        • Annotations
        • Installation
        • Examples
        • Overview
        • Installation
        • Configurations
        • Examples
      • Overview
      • Vault Lambda Extension
      • Running Vault
      • Overview
      • Installation
      • Configuration
      • Troubleshooting
      • Overview
      • Installation
      • Configuration
      • Upgrading
      • Troubleshooting

    • Overview
    • Upgrade Plugins
    • Upgrade to 1.11.x
    • Upgrade to 1.10.x
    • Upgrade to 1.9.x
    • Upgrade to 1.8.x
    • Upgrade to 1.7.x
    • Upgrade to 1.6.3
    • Upgrade to 1.6.2
    • Upgrade to 1.6.1
    • Upgrade to 1.6.0
    • Upgrade to 1.5.3
    • Upgrade to 1.5.2
    • Upgrade to 1.5.1
    • Upgrade to 1.5.0
    • Upgrade to 1.4.6
    • Upgrade to 1.4.5
    • Upgrade to 1.4.4
    • Upgrade to 1.4.1
    • Upgrade to 1.4.0
    • Upgrade to 1.3.10
    • Upgrade to 1.3.9
    • Upgrade to 1.3.8
    • Upgrade to 1.3.5
    • Upgrade to 1.3.4
    • Upgrade to 1.3.3
    • Upgrade to 1.3.2
    • Upgrade to 1.3.0
    • Upgrade to 1.2.7
    • Upgrade to 1.2.6
    • Upgrade to 1.2.5
    • Upgrade to 1.2.4
    • Upgrade to 1.2.1
    • Upgrade to 1.2.0
    • Upgrade to 1.1.2
    • Upgrade to 1.1.1
    • Upgrade to 1.1.0
    • Upgrade to 1.0.0
    • Upgrade to 0.11.6
    • Upgrade to 0.11.2
    • Upgrade to 0.11.0
    • Upgrade to 0.10.4
    • Upgrade to 0.10.2
    • Upgrade to 0.10.0
    • Upgrade to 0.9.6
    • Upgrade to 0.9.3
    • Upgrade to 0.9.2
    • Upgrade to 0.9.1
    • Upgrade to 0.9.0
    • Upgrade to 0.8.0
    • Upgrade to 0.7.0
    • Upgrade to 0.6.4
    • Upgrade to 0.6.3
    • Upgrade to 0.6.2
    • Upgrade to 0.6.1
    • Upgrade to 0.6.0
    • Upgrade to 0.5.1
    • Upgrade to 0.5.0

    • Overview
    • 1.11.0
    • 1.10.0
    • 1.9.0
    • 1.8.0
    • 1.7.0
    • 1.6.0
    • 1.5.0

    • Overview
    • FAQ

    • Overview
    • Feature Deprecation Notice and Plans
    • License
    • Client Count
    • Login MFA
    • Server Side Consistent Token

  • Glossary

    • Overview
      • Overview
      • Autoloading
      • FAQ
    • Replication
      • Overview
      • Behavioral Changes
      • Security
    • Automated Integrated Storage Snapshots
    • Automated Upgrades
    • Redundancy Zones
    • Lease Count Quotas
    • Entropy Augmentation
      • Overview
      • FIPS 140-2 Inside Vault
      • Seal Wrap for FIPS 140-2
    • Seal Wrap
    • Namespaces
    • Performance Standbys
    • Eventual Consistency
    • Control Groups
    • Managed Keys
      • Overview
      • Duo MFA
      • Okta MFA
      • PingID MFA
      • TOTP MFA
      • Overview
      • Examples
      • Properties
    • HCP Vault

The Vault website is being redesigned to help you find what you are looking for more effectively.

Type '/' to Search

»FF3-1 Tweak Usage Documentation

»Introduction

The Vault Transform Secrets Engine uses the FF3-1 algorithm for FPE (format preserving encryption) transformations. The key benefit of format preserving encryption schemes is that it allows for the secure encryption of plaintexts over small domain spaces [1]. However, this comes with the introduction of a parameter called the tweak, which is supplied to the FF3-1 algorithm. Up until recently, the formal definitions of security in FPE schemes have assumed that an attacker only has access to one tweak when probing the codebook for a particular key. However, following the work of Bellare, this notion was changed to assume that an attacker could control multiple tweaks when generating a codebook and trying to create a nontrivial distinguisher for FF3-1.

This page will detail some best practices when using tweaks.

Note that this guidance only holds when the tweak source selected when using the Vault FF3-1 transform is supplied or internal.

»FF3-1 Best Practices:

Vault recommends the following practices when utilizing tweaks with the FF3-1 transform.

  • Encryption should be as restricted as possible via ACLs.
  • Tweaks are not user controlled, but are randomly chosen and treated as sensitive (if not secret).
  • Tweaks make use of the max length allowed for the bytestring, and have high entropy (as uniformly variable as possible over the max tweak domain space and differing with each encryption). Tweaks should utilize the full domain space.
  • Care should be taken to ensure that the same tweak is not used to encrypt two of the same values that correspond to different underlying entities.

The following section aims to give some broad motivation for these recommendations. For details, please see the Further Resources section at the bottom of the page.

»FF3-1 Tweak Usage

FF3-1 is a tweakable encryption scheme that was created to solve the problem of encrypting on small domains. Tweaks were introduced to synthetically increase the domain space. With the introduction of tweaks, an attacker must now have the correct encryption of the plaintext and the correct tweak in order to backtrack via a codebook from an encryption to a plaintext.

However, this can be risky when the number of tweaks used in FF3-1 setups is too small or is chosen on a restricted domain, or when it is user-generated and access control on encrypting is too broad. In the former case, a codebook can still be easily created if the tweaks are known (since tweak values are not necessarily secret [3]). In the latter case, an attacker who gains access to encrypting data (ie, has chosen-plaintext strength) can manipulate the tweaks to essentially bypass that synthetic extension of the domain space.

Another observation to note about FF3-1 is that encrypting the same plaintext with the same key and tweak is deterministic, so two plaintexts that happen to coincide will lead to two ciphertexts that coincide. Thus, no matching plaintexts for different objects should be stored with the same tweaks. For example, if the ciphertexts corresponding to the last four digits of phone numbers are stored, then there may be plaintext collisions, and these collision values should not be encrypted with the same tweak [3, Appendix C].

As a third observation, FF3-1 splits tweaks in half and uses half a tweak in each round function. Therefore, ideally, randomly chosen tweaks should have high entropy within each half of the tweak. In the worst case scenario, creating many encryptions with tweaks with the same right or left half will lead to more biased encryptions (where the distinction between the corresponding encryptions rely solely on the randomness of the abelian summation operator). In practice, using randomly chosen tweaks will be enough -- however, it is important to avoid using an algorithm to generate tweaks that yields similarity between two halves of tweaks [4].

»Further Resources:

  • 1: https://eprint.iacr.org/2020/1311.pdf
  • 2: https://csrc.nist.gov/news/2017/recent-cryptanalysis-of-ff3
  • 3: https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/specialpublications/nist.sp.800-38g.pdf
  • 4: https://img.chainnews.com/paper/568b1f587c93f63832f083dd449107c2.pdf
github logoEdit this page
DocsAPILearnCommunityPrivacySecurityPress KitConsent Manager